Skip to main content
We have begun the founding chapter. Be among the first

Guest Essay

Google’s School Search Controversy Exposes a Bigger Problem. Who Really Controls Our Digital World?

Google says schools that switch off its AI could lose Search too. Gareth Evans, CEO of Timpi, argues the dispute shows how much power a few companies hold over services everyone depends on, and what a more open internet would need.

By Gareth Evans, Member, AI Trust CouncilNovember 12, 2026
Chief Executive Officer and Co-Founder, Timpi.

Disclosure. Gareth Evans is a member of the AI Trust Council, which governs the Trust Identity Protocol described in this essay. He is CEO and Co-Founder of Timpi, which the essay discusses, and Timpi is a contracted Founding Node Operator of the TIP network in New Zealand. Rooverse, also discussed, has adopted TIP, and its CEO, Ross Thorpe, is Chairman of the AI Trust Council. The AI Lab publishes Insights.

A white Google sign with the multicolored Google logo and the address 1565 and 1585 Charleston Road, set among tall redwood trees on Google's campus in Mountain View, California.
Google’s campus sign on Charleston Road in Mountain View, California, August 2022. Photo by Dietmar Rabich / Wikimedia Commons / “Mountain View (CA, USA), Charleston Road, Google-Schild -- 2022 -- 2896” / CC BY-SA 4.0. Cropped.

Google is at the center of a growing controversy after announcing changes to its education services that could leave schools without Google Search if they choose to restrict the use of AI.

The announcement drew criticism from educators, politicians and technology commentators, and it raises uncomfortable questions about the power a handful of technology companies now hold over essential digital services.

Beyond the immediate controversy lies a much bigger issue. As our schools, businesses, governments and communities come to depend on a small number of technology providers, who gets to decide how those services are used, what rules govern them and what happens when we disagree?

When saying no to AI means losing access to Search

On November 3, Google announced changes to its education services, including new controls that let school administrators manage access to Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom and Google Search.

Under the changes, these services will be switched off by default for K-12 student accounts until administrators turn them on. Google has not yet set a date. It says schools will get details in the coming months, and the controls will roll out worldwide, starting in the United States.

On the surface, this sounds like a positive step. Schools have raised concerns about the impact of AI on education, particularly students relying on AI-generated answers instead of developing their own critical thinking and problem-solving skills.

However, there is a significant complication.

Chris Phillips, Google’s vice president and general manager of education, explained that Search and AI are now deeply integrated. If a school chooses not to enable Google’s AI tools, its students could also lose access to Google Search.

For schools that want to keep students away from generative AI while keeping conventional search, that is a difficult choice.

US Senator Bernie Sanders called Google’s position extortion, writing, “Google is threatening schools: if you stop your students from using AI, we will cut off your access to Google Search.”

Former Federal Trade Commission chair Lina Khan wrote that Google was using its search monopoly to “coerce schools into adopting AI,” and warned of the danger of letting an unregulated monopolist control an essential service. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani wrote that “no corporation should have the power to dictate how we teach our children.”

For educators already struggling to set boundaries around AI in classrooms, the announcement raised a hard question. Should rejecting a technology company’s AI strategy mean losing access to one of the internet’s most fundamental tools?

Google says schools get more choice, not less

Google has pushed back against the criticism, arguing that its announcement gives schools more control.

In a clarification posted on X, the company said Gemini, Gemini Notebook and Search would all be switched off by default, and administrators could enable each product according to their school’s requirements.

Google also said it has been listening to educators who are concerned about students using AI to shortcut their schoolwork.

As part of its response, Google is introducing Guided Learning into Search and Google Classroom. Rather than simply giving students answers, the system is designed to guide them through problems with questions and step-by-step explanations, so they understand the material.

Google argues that AI can be used responsibly in education and that schools should have the tools to manage how it is introduced.

That argument has merit. AI has enormous potential to improve education, and responsible AI-assisted learning could bring real benefits to students and teachers.

But Google’s response doesn’t remove the underlying concern. Google says Search and AI are deeply integrated, so a school that wants Search gets Google’s AI with it. The question is whether schools have a genuine choice when the search service they depend on is tied to the technology they may wish to restrict.

Google’s position shows how much influence a single technology provider can have once institutions depend on its ecosystem.

And that is where this story becomes considerably bigger than Google.

The growing problem with Big Tech dependency

For years, individuals, businesses, schools and governments have steadily moved their digital lives onto platforms controlled by a small number of technology companies.

Search, social media, communications, cloud infrastructure, productivity software, data storage and now artificial intelligence are concentrated in the hands of a few major providers.

These companies have built extraordinary products and services. There is no denying the contribution they have made to technology and to the accessibility of information.

But as their influence has grown, so has the reach of their decisions.

A change to a platform’s policies, pricing, algorithms, technical requirements or terms of service can have consequences far beyond the company’s immediate customer base.

Schools may find themselves adapting educational policies to accommodate technology platforms. Businesses can become locked into proprietary ecosystems. Communities can lose access to services or audiences when platform rules change. Governments can find critical infrastructure dependent on providers operating under the laws and policies of another country.

These companies may never intend to exercise control over everyone who uses their products. The concentration of digital infrastructure gives them the ability to.

When there are few practical alternatives, choice exists mostly on paper.

This is the fundamental problem with digital dependency. The organizations using these services are technically free to leave, but the cost, complexity and disruption of leaving can make that freedom difficult to exercise.

Countries are beginning to push back

The debate around Google’s education services is part of a much wider shift in how governments and institutions think about their digital future.

Across Europe, digital sovereignty has become a political and strategic priority.

On June 3, 2026, the European Commission presented its Tech Sovereignty package, measures designed to strengthen Europe’s ability to develop and control critical technologies, infrastructure and data while reducing reliance on providers outside the European Union.

The Commission says Europe relies on non-EU countries for more than 80 percent of its key digital products, services and infrastructure.

Where data is stored is only part of it. What matters is the ability to make independent decisions about the technologies that underpin a country’s economy, public services and society.

We are already seeing practical examples of this shift.

France plans to move about 2.5 million civil servants away from Microsoft Teams, Zoom, Webex and other US video tools by 2027, onto Visio, a domestically developed video conferencing platform.

The German state of Schleswig-Holstein has migrated 44,000 employee email inboxes away from Microsoft and moved its file-sharing infrastructure to open-source alternatives.

Austria’s military has moved from Microsoft Office to LibreOffice, an open-source office suite.

These decisions are driven by concerns about security, data protection, vendor dependency and the ability to keep control of essential digital infrastructure.

Governments are no longer comfortable placing all their digital infrastructure in the hands of a few external providers.

And this thinking should not stop at government infrastructure. Schools, businesses, communities and individuals have just as much reason to question their dependence on technology they do not control.

Digital sovereignty should not be something reserved for governments. It should be something available to everyone.

Three approaches

A different internet is possible

The answer is a more open and diverse digital ecosystem where people have genuine alternatives, without abandoning technology, rejecting AI or simply replacing one large technology company with another.

An internet where search is not dependent on a single provider, where social platforms serve their communities rather than dictate how they interact, and where individuals keep greater control over their identity, information and digital presence.

Projects are already working toward different parts of this vision.

  1. Timpi and independent access to information

    Independent search timpi.io

    Search engines have become one of the most influential gateways to information in the world.

    Yet the majority of global search activity is concentrated around a handful of companies, giving them enormous influence over how information is discovered, ranked and presented.

    Timpi is taking a different approach by building independent, decentralized search infrastructure.

    Rather than relying on a single corporate-owned index, Timpi is developing its own web index supported by a distributed network. Its focus is privacy-first search, without user tracking or profiling, delivering information without the commercial dependencies that dominate much of today’s search market.

    The aim is that search should be an open gateway to information, not another way for individuals to become the product.

    Timpi is currently available in public beta, with its index, coverage and search capabilities continuing to develop.

  2. Rooverse and social media built for people

    Human-only social network rooverse.app

    Social media was originally about connecting people, sharing experiences and building communities.

    But today’s dominant platforms have become algorithm-driven environments, where engagement, advertising and automated content compete for users’ attention.

    Rooverse is exploring a different model. It describes itself as a human-only social network built around authentic human connection, and says it removes bots, algorithmic feeds and AI-generated content.

    Its philosophy is that social platforms should exist to serve the people using them, not to maximize engagement or decide what content people should see.

    The idea is that online communities should have spaces where human interaction remains the priority.

  3. The AI Lab and trust in a changing digital world

    Identity and content provenance theailab.org

    As AI-generated content becomes harder to tell apart from human-created material, another challenge is emerging. How do we know who created something, whether it has been altered and how it was produced?

    The AI Lab is addressing this through its Trust Identity Protocol (TIP).

    The protocol is designed to provide verified digital identity and content provenance, allowing creators to establish ownership of their work and declare whether content is human-created, AI-assisted, AI-generated or a combination of these.

    That makes it part of the wider conversation about digital independence.

    The future of the internet will involve AI, but that doesn’t mean we should abandon transparency, accountability or the ability to understand where information originates.

    People should be able to make informed decisions about the content they consume and the technology they interact with.

The future of the internet shouldn’t belong to a handful of corporations

There is an important distinction between building successful technology and controlling the infrastructure that society depends upon.

The major technology companies have helped create the modern internet. But their success should not mean that they become the permanent gatekeepers of our digital future.

The Google school controversy shows what can happen when an organization becomes so deeply embedded in everyday life that its product decisions have consequences for institutions with very different priorities.

And while this particular debate centers on AI in education, the underlying issue extends much further.

It is about whether schools can choose how technology is used in their classrooms. Whether governments can maintain control over their own digital infrastructure. Whether communities can build their own online spaces. Whether individuals can access information without surrendering their privacy or becoming dependent on a single provider.

It comes down to choice.

We don’t need an internet without Google, Microsoft, Meta or AI. We need an internet where their existence does not prevent freedom of choice.

An internet where no single company has the ability to dictate the conditions under which the rest of the world participates.

That means supporting open standards, independent infrastructure, decentralized networks and services built around the interests of their users and communities.

Timpi, Rooverse and The AI Lab are examples of different approaches to that challenge. They are part of a broader effort to explore what a more independent, transparent and human-centered digital ecosystem could look like.

The next evolution of the internet should make sure that power is not concentrated in the hands of those who own the platforms. The internet was built on the promise of openness, access and freedom. It’s time we started building it that way again.

Sources


Gareth Evans is the Chief Executive Officer and Co-Founder of Timpi, building the infrastructure for a more open internet through scalable web indexing and data services that enable fair, transparent, and unbiased access to information. The Timpi ecosystem spans Search, Browser, Data APIs, Intelligence Services, and VPN technology, empowering individuals and organisations to navigate the digital world without compromise. Timpi is a contracted Founding Node Operator of the TIP Protocol federated network in New Zealand, bringing operational leadership of trust-infrastructure deployment across the Asia Pacific to the Council.

Views in guest essays are the author’s own. Read how the Trust Identity Protocol works, or meet the AI Trust Council.